I've been poking around in Nelson Algren's The Neon Wilderness and the critical edition of The Man with The Golden Arm. The rap against Algren is evidently that he sentimentalizes the working class and the underclass. At least in the stories I've read in The Neon Wilderness, this isn't true.
I compare what I read in Algren with what I read in Kerouac's Windblown Journals, which I thought did sentimentalize working people. Two differences stand out: 1) Abstraction. There are no actual people in Kerouac. 2) Escapism. Kerouac wants to be a laborer because he wants a vacation from human complexity, which he somehow thinks is the province of the educated.
Neither of these--abstraction, escapism--are present in the Algren I've read.
Maybe it's time to spin Fitzgerald's famous reply to Hemingway: the poor are different from us.
Yes, they have less money.
This all matters to me because I am writing about farmers, who get condescended to all the time. And because the cubicle class has such contempt for anyone who actually uses a muscle.
Progress report: yesterday, half an hour revisiting the problematic chapter. The subchapters are starting to emerge.
Recent Comments